Cao Cao
Cao's Forces, Leader 
[ico0(1)]Hero of Chaos
Posts: 955
|
Post by Cao Cao on Sept 14, 2010 18:00:14 GMT
Okay, who do you think would win if the warriors of the Three Kingdoms Era(Dynasty Warriors) fought the warriors of Feudal Japan (Samurai Warriors)? I do not know much about actual Feudal Japan other than the Samurai and I can't base it off of my knowledge of the Samurai Warriors game so I wanted to get your guys' opinion about it, so I CAN choose.  |
|
Lu Xiang
Leader
The Eagle of the North
Posts: 3,658
|
Post by Lu Xiang on Sept 14, 2010 19:29:31 GMT
If we are talking historical, this is easy. Of course the Samurai are going to win; they are almost 1000 years ahead of their Three Kingdoms friends. And thus their tactics, knowledge of war, society, weapon advancement, numbers, understandment of battlefields and much more is going to far ahead. Not only this, it is most likely their weapons would also be better. If we are pitting them off against eachother with guns, then it is an easy win.
Samurai were masters upon horseback as well as single one on one. I doubt the Chinese would've stood much chance against Feudal Japan. However if they were to meet in the same timezone, under fair conditions then this would change. Then it would resolve on significant figures. Many of the Chinese Generals and Comparable to the Japanese (as seen in Warriors Orochi).
The question truly would be.. Chinese Three Kingdoms Generals vs. Japan Feudal Generals on even ground, neither side showing as advantage with troops or battle advantage. (Obviously this is never achieveable, one side will always show an advantage - even in the slightest)
I will pretend that nobody was stubborn back in these ages and were willing to work together. For the Three Kingdoms side, we'd have Cao Cao matched by Nobunaga of course. I personally would consider Cao Cao far more significant - though Nobunaga alone could just be his match. (Fair play to Koei)
Zhuge has Shingen. Sima Yi has Kenshin. Yukimura has Zhao Yun. Lu Bu has Tadagatsu. etc.
Overall general wise, the Chinese had more significants; but its two sifferent complete shades of life. It would depend completely where they meet and I think it'd be a tough battle to decide. Both sides have strengths and weaknesses, to some extent "evenly matched".
|
|
Cao Pi
Cao Cao's Forces
[ico0(1)]
Posts: 416
|
Post by Cao Pi on Sept 14, 2010 19:49:06 GMT
1V1 it would be close but 1000 samurai vs 1000 men lead by say Cao Cao, the Samurai would win.
|
|
|
|
Post by Yen Wang (Burai) on Sept 14, 2010 21:11:40 GMT
DW vs SW?
My money would have to go with SW, they have some epic warriors
number 1 contender Tadakatsu Honda(greatest warrior in history IMO) They have to many kickass people
Though DW has a few. Lu Bu vs Tadakatsu Honda; Tadakatsu Honda could be but ass naked and armed with a pair of chop sticks and Lu Bu would be outmatched.
|
|
